The 2025 Reality: If your engineering department is still calculating machine assignment based on the classic deterministic model ($Cycle = Max(Man, Machine)$), your production standards are, in all likelihood, overestimated by between 5% and 15%.
In plants with high automation or flexible manufacturing cells, variability is not the exception, it is the norm. The real challenge for the Plant Engineer today is not to achieve theoretical Mechanical Saturation, but to optimize the Total Expected Cost (TEC) by managing the stochasticity of the system.
From the Engineering Division of Cronometras, we present this technical guide on the transition from the static chart to dynamic modeling, integrating the Ashcroft interference tables and the new cognitive ergonomics requirements of the ISO 10075 standard.
Technical Fundamentals of the Combined Cycle (Critical Variables)
To standardize the technical language and avoid ambiguity in time studies, it is imperative to define the variables with mathematical rigor before applying any assignment algorithm.
Breakdown of Times ($TE, TI, TT$)
The correct segregation of times is the first step toward the viability of the system:
- External Time ($TE$): Comprises all manual activity that the operator must necessarily perform with the machine stopped (e.g., loading/unloading, centering the part).
- Technical Note: Reducing is the main objective of SMED methodologies. A high directly penalizes machine availability.
- Internal Time ($TI$): Manual activity performed by the operator while the machine is in its automatic cycle (e.g., deburring, dimensional inspection, packaging). This time is "free" from the machine cycle perspective, provided that .
- Process Time ($TT$): Automatic process time.
- The common mistake: Considering an absolute constant. In CNC machining or plastics injection processes, variables such as material hardness or temperature can introduce variations. For the H-M calculation, the standard deviation ($\sigma$) of the must be used for robust models.
The Theoretical Assignment Formula ($N$)
The theoretical number of machines ($N$) that one operator can attend is defined by the ratio between the total cycle and the time devoted per machine:
The integer-number dilemma: The result of is rarely an integer. The engineer faces a binary decision with financial consequences:
- Option (lower integer): The operator has idle times (low saturation). The machines never wait for the operator. Production per machine is maximized.
- Option (upper integer): The operator is oversaturated. The machines wait for attention (interference). Labor productivity is maximized, but OEE per machine drops.
The Error of Determinism: Machine Interference Calculation
Here lies the "Pain Point" of most traditional industrial time studies. By assuming that cycles are perfectly synchronized "Swiss watches," Machine Interference ($I$) is ignored.
From Theory to Stochastic Reality
Interference occurs when one or more machines stop (end of cycle or random stoppage) while the operator is busy attending another machine. In a deterministic system, this is "drawn" so that it does not happen. In stochastic reality, the entropy of the system generates waiting queues.
Ignoring random interference and desynchronization reduces actual production relative to theoretical production, invalidating production incentives and the calculation of standard costs.
Application of the Ashcroft Tables and Wright Formulas
To calculate the time lost to interference in systems of machines attended by one server, we must resort to probabilistic models (M/M/1 or M/M/c Queueing Theory).
- Ashcroft Tables: They use the Service Coefficient ($ \rho = \frac{TE+TI}{TT} $) and the number of machines ($n$) to return the average expected percentage of interference.
- Example: An operator with 4 machines and a service coefficient of 20% does not have 0% interference (as simple arithmetic would suggest), but statistically close to 12.4% according to the Ashcroft tables, due to the probability of coinciding stoppages.
- Wright Formulas: Recommended when the machine cycle times differ significantly from one another.
Spain 2025 Regulatory Framework: Cognitive Ergonomics and Safety
Methods engineering in 2025 must respond not only to productivity, but to strict legal compliance. The authority of Cronometras is based on integrating ILO and ISO standards into the technical calculation.
ISO 10075 and Mental Workload in Multi-Machine Tasks
Labor Inspection is shifting its focus toward psychosocial workload. An H-M chart that saturates the operator at 98% is technically feasible on paper, but illegal and unsustainable in practice under the UNE-EN ISO 10075 (Ergonomic principles related to mental workload) standard.
- Divided-Attention Fatigue: Managing multiple asynchronous processes increases cognitive fatigue.
- The 85% Limit: At Cronometras, we recommend setting an active saturation limit of 85%. The remaining 15% is not "leisure"; it is a cognitive recovery buffer and for handling untabulated micro-incidents.
- ILO Allowances ($K$): Rest coefficients must be recalculated by penalizing the simultaneous monitoring of high-risk or high-precision processes.
Safety in the Interaction (Industry 4.0)
Integrating safety into the standard cycle is non-negotiable. The times must include the safety protocols.
- Digital LOTO: If the machine requires safe stoppages for loading/unloading, the lockout and unlock time (software or hardware) is part of the Standard Cycle, not an unproductive time. Ignoring it causes safety violations due to time pressure.
Cronometras Methodology: Economic vs. Technical Optimization
How do we decide the final assignment? The answer is not technical, it is financial.
Minimum Unit Cost Criterion
The objective is to minimize the cost per piece produced, not necessarily to maximize gross output. The decision formula we propose to plant managements is:
Sensitivity Analysis:
- If the Machine Hourly Cost is high (e.g., 5-axis Machining Centers), the strategy must be to minimize machine interference (assign low , operator with idle times).
- If the Labor Cost is the main driver (simple processes, fully depreciated machines), the strategy is to saturate the operator (assign high , accepting machine stoppages).
Time Standardization with MOST and MTM
"From scratch" time study is inefficient for designing multi-machine cells. The time must be predicted before physical implementation.
- The "Walking Time" factor: In H-M charts, movement between machines is the most critical and volatile variable.
- Use of Basic MOST: We use Maynard Operation Sequence Technique to simulate different layouts. MOST allows us to calculate precisely the impact of changing the machine arrangement (reducing meters traveled) without moving a single piece of equipment, validating the feasibility of the cycle.
Practical Implementation: From Excel to MES (Digital Twin)
Audit of Concurrent Times
The first step is to audit the current standards. Many ERPs contain routings with times calculated years ago under deterministic assumptions. It is vital to recalculate installed capacity by applying the Ashcroft interference factors to obtain realistic Capacity Planning.
Integration with MES Systems
The H-M chart must not be a static document. It must be fed by the MES (Manufacturing Execution System). By capturing actual micro-stoppages and cycle variability in real time, we can dynamically adjust the number of machines assigned per shift, creating a dynamic and adaptive OEE.
Conclusions for the Engineering Management
Machine assignment in 2025 requires abandoning arithmetic simplicity in favor of statistical modeling and regulatory compliance. The three pillars for a successful implementation are:
- Interference Modeling: Mandatory use of Ashcroft Tables or queueing simulation to predict the real loss of OEE.
- Cognitive Limit: Respect the 85% saturation ceiling (ISO 10075) to ensure sustainable quality and safety.
- Rigorous Standardization: Use of MOST/MTM standards to set the manual and movement times, eliminating the subjectivity of direct time study.
Do your time standards ignore machine interference or cognitive load? The difference between theoretical and actual production is lost money. Request a technical saturation and methods audit with the Engineering Division of Cronometras.
Article developed by the Cronometras technical team – Specialists in Methods and Time Engineering.
Don't want to do it yourself? We do it for you from €800
If you prefer to outsource it, Cronometras delivers a complete time and motion study from a single video: elemental breakdown, OIT/TAL fatigue allowances, standard time with tolerances, and a report in PDF + Excel + JSON ready to present to management.