Time Study of Complex Frequent Elements

Time Study of Complex Frequent Elements

• Cronometras Team

How to measure frequent elements in work study: technical prorating, work sampling, standard time, OEE impact and 2025 ergonomics and data compliance.

In modern methods engineering, the measurement of repetitive cyclical elements has become a commodity. Any junior analyst can time-study a 30-second cycle on a stable assembly line. However, the true productivity gap in Spanish industry —especially in High Mix / Low Volume environments— lies in the "Gray Zone": those elements that do not occur in every cycle, but that are essential to process continuity.

We are talking about frequent elements. Their incorrect measurement (or their omission) is the root cause of OEE deviations of up to 15% and of standard costs that do not reflect the reality of the Shop Floor.

Technical Definition: What Is a Frequent Element in Work Study?

According to the ILO guidelines and the leading technical literature (Niebel/Freivalds), an element is classified as frequent when it occurs at regular or random intervals after NN production cycles, but not in every one of them.

Difference between cyclical, frequent and contingency elements

For the plant engineer, the distinction is critical for cost allocation:

  1. Cyclical Element: Occurs once per part (e.g. "Screw component A"). It is allocated directly to the Cycle Time ($Tc$).
  2. Frequent Element: Occurs every XX parts (e.g. "Change CNC insert every 50 parts" or "Refill hopper every 200 units"). It must technically be prorated.
  3. Contingency: Random events not inherent to the method (breakdowns, waiting for material). These are covered by allowances, not by standard times.

The most common methodological error is to treat a frequent element as a contingency, applying a general percentage "buffer" (e.g. 5%) to the total time. This is a bad practice that conceals inefficiency.

Why the "Snapback" method fails in non-repetitive tasks

Snapback time study is ineffective at capturing the variability of frequent elements. If an analyst is measuring a short cycle and a frequent element occurs (e.g. cleaning of accumulated burrs), they tend to discard that reading as "abnormal". In doing so, they remove a legitimate part of the workload from the study, generating a standard that cannot be met (a "tight" standard).

To capture these events without bias, advanced digital tools such as Cronometras make it possible to tag events in-situ or through video analysis, ensuring that these times are not discarded, but instead isolated for subsequent calculation.

The Hidden Impact on OEE and Industrial Cost

The incorrect definition of frequent elements devastates the accuracy of OEE (Overall Equipment Effectiveness).

The error of general allowances: Inflating the Standard Time

If we include tasks such as "area cleaning" within a fixed 7% allowance for "process needs", we are assuming that the required time is proportional to the length of the shift, which is false. Cleaning time is proportional to the amount of swarf generated (production volume). By using fixed allowances, we inflate cost during low production and strangle the operator during high production.

Speed Loss vs. Saturated Cycle Time

When an MES system or a production control platform such as Induly records a drop in parts/hour, the engineer must discern: Is it a speed loss (micro-stop) or the legitimate execution of a frequent element?

If the Standard Time does not include the prorating of the frequent element ($T_{frec}$), the system will report a false performance loss every time the operator performs that necessary task. For real cost traceability, the industrial time and attendance system must be fed with times that integrate this mathematical variability.

Calculation Methodology: Mathematics of Technical Prorating

To integrate these elements into the Standard Time ($TE$), the total time is not simply added; it is prorated.

The formula for Frequent Standard Time ($TE_{frec}$)

The technical equation for allocating the cost of a frequent element to the unit cycle is:

TEfrec=(TO×Act)×(1+Supl)NTE_{frec} = \frac{(TO \times Act) \times (1 + Supl)}{N}

Where:

  • TOTO: Average Observed Time of the frequent element.
  • ActAct: Activity Factor (Pace or Performance, hundred-point scale or Bedaux).
  • SuplSupl: Allowances for fatigue and personal needs.
  • NN: Frequency of occurrence (e.g. 1 time every 50 cycles).

Statistical determination of the variable NN (Frequency)

The great challenge is not measuring the time ($TO$), but determining NN. Does the operator really clean the machine every 50 cycles, or does he do it every 35? This is where the stopwatch fails, since it would require days of continuous observation.

Work Sampling vs. Direct Time Study

To determine the frequency NN with scientific validity, the superior technique is Work Sampling (Tippett Method). Instead of observing continuously, random observations are carried out over a representative period (a week or a month).

  • Application: If in 1.000 random observations, the operator is seen performing the frequent element in 50 of them, we have a PP (percentage of occurrence) of 5%.
  • Recommended tool: Carrying out thousands of observations with paper and pencil is unfeasible today. The use of professional applications such as WorkSamp enables engineers to conduct sampling studies with random alerts and automatic calculation of the margin of error and confidence level (generally aiming for 95% confidence ±\pm 5% error). Once the frequency has been validated with WorkSamp, the stopwatch is used to measure the exact duration of that specific task.

Predetermined Time Systems (MTM and MOST) in Irregular Tasks

When frequent elements are complex and manual (e.g. irregular palletizing, box preparation), performance rating (Activity) by subjective assessment is dangerous. The operator usually works at a different pace on tasks that are not automatic.

Limitations of performance rating

In sporadic tasks, there is no "muscle automaticity". An analyst might rate a pace of 80 (BSI) when the method is actually inefficient.

Use of Basic MOST and MTM-UAS

To standardize these operations, it is recommended to abandon the stopwatch and use predetermined time systems:

  • MTM-UAS (Universal Analysing System): Ideal for batch processes and auxiliary tasks.
  • Basic MOST: Excellent for general movements of medium duration.
  • MaxiMOST: Specifically designed for long-cycle operations, maintenance and machine setups, where millisecond accuracy is less critical than method consistency.

2025 Regulatory Framework: Ergonomics and Digitalization in Spain

Methods engineering can no longer be separated from risk prevention and data legality.

Link with UNE-EN ISO 11228

Frequent elements are often the most physically demanding (e.g. lifting a 20kg coil every 30 minutes). Under ISO 11228 regulation (Manual handling of loads), a time study is incomplete if it does not audit the ergonomic risk of these effort peaks. The standard time must include the fatigue recovery coefficients derived from methods such as NIOSH or OCRA, applied specifically to those frequent elements.

GDPR and Algorithmic Transparency

With the rise of industrial video analysis, capturing task frequency through fixed cameras involves legal challenges. The new EU AI regulation and the GDPR require transparency. If you use software to determine times, you must be able to justify to the Works Council how the frequency NN has been calculated. A sampling study carried out with auditable tools such as WorkSamp offers a much more robust technical defense than an eyeball estimate or a "black box" video analysis.

Implementation Strategy for Plant Engineers

To master variability, follow this technical workflow:

  1. Identification: List all tasks that do not occur in every cycle (use the Pareto Diagram to prioritize those with the greatest impact).
  2. Frequency Validation ($N$): Do not guess. Run a Work Sampling study over 5-10 shifts using a digital app to obtain the real percentage of occurrence.
  3. Duration Measurement: Once the frequency is known, isolate the task and measure it precisely (using Cronometras or MTM) to obtain the Normal Time.
  4. Calculation and Export: Apply the prorating formula and export the structured data (PDF/Excel/JSON) so that your cost system correctly absorbs these auxiliary activities. There is no direct integration with ERP or costing systems beyond these structured exports (Induly separately covers personnel time and attendance).

The time study of frequent elements is the frontier that separates a simple "time taker" from a Productivity Engineer. Precision in these details defines the plant's real profitability.


Don't want to do it yourself? We do it for you from €800

If you prefer to outsource it, Cronometras delivers a complete time and motion study from a single video: elemental breakdown, OIT/TAL fatigue allowances, standard time with tolerances, and a report in PDF + Excel + JSON ready to present to management.

👉 Request the study from €800 · More about Cronometras

Did you find this useful?

Share this article with your professional network